Southeastern University's regular season ended in heartbreak Saturday night at Gyrene Field, where the Fire fell 48-45 in overtime to Sun Conference rival Ave Maria. Despite piling up 592 yards of total offense—more than 200 yards over Ave Maria's 384—Southeastern (7-3, 4-3 Sun Conference) could not overcome early turnovers, nine penalties for 106 yards, and a missed field goal in the first overtime period. The defeat deals a significant blow to the Fire's NAIA Football Championship Series playoff hopes as they await the postseason selection announcement.
Ave Maria (7-4, 5-2) seized momentum in the opening quarter after intercepting Southeastern quarterback Zach Pleuss on the Fire's first offensive series. Three plays later, Gyrenes wide receiver Oliver Neiman connected with quarterback Logan Howard on a 27-yard trick-play touchdown pass, followed by a 48-yard Jeremy Burch field goal to give the hosts a 10-0 lead. The Fire defense came up with a key stop late in the quarter when defensive back
Jermaine Tyler Jr. intercepted Howard at the SEU 19-yard line, setting a new Southeastern single-season interception record with his eighth pick of the year. Southeastern found its rhythm in the second quarter behind running back Connor McCazzio, who scored on a 14-yard run to put the Fire on the board. Pleuss then hit
David Wacenske for a 4-yard touchdown pass late in the half, though Ave Maria answered each score to carry a 24-14 advantage into the break.
The two teams traded haymakers throughout a high-scoring second half. Southeastern opened the third quarter with a methodical 14-play, 75-yard march capped by a 1-yard touchdown grab from Wacenske. After Howard hit Neiman for a 64-yard strike, Pleuss responded immediately with a 63-yard touchdown bomb to
Tre McClellan to keep the Fire within 31-28. Ave Maria stretched its lead back to 10 early in the fourth quarter, setting up a frantic Southeastern rally. Pleuss found
Omar Mejia for an 11-yard score with 5:33 remaining, and after the Fire defense forced a turnover on downs, Pleuss hit McCazzio for a 49-yard gain to set up McCazzio's 5-yard go-ahead rushing touchdown with 1:54 left.
Ave Maria refused to fold, marching 75 yards in just over a minute to reclaim a 45-42 lead on a 29-yard touchdown pass from Howard to Neiman with 38 seconds on the clock. Taking over at its own 35-yard line with no timeouts, Southeastern engineered a clutch six-play drive highlighted by a 45-yard completion from Pleuss to defensive back
Jamil Jones, allowing kicker
Joel McGrath to drill a game-tying 27-yard field goal with 10 seconds left in regulation.
Southeastern took the ball first in overtime and drove down to the Ave Maria 7-yard line behind three carries from McCazzio and a 5-yard completion to Wacenske. However, after a third-down pass fell incomplete, McGrath's 24-yard field goal attempt sailed wide left. Ave Maria capitalized on the reprieve, advancing to the 1-yard line before Burch converted an 18-yard walk-off field goal to seal the 48-45 victory.
Pleuss finished the night 34-of-49 passing for 466 yards, four touchdowns, and two interceptions, bringing his season total to 2,717 yards to break Southeastern's single-season passing yards record. McCazzio led the ground attack with 120 yards and two touchdowns on 18 carries while adding 88 receiving yards on five catches. McClellan paced the receiving corps with 120 yards on five receptions, Wacenske hauled in 11 passes for 73 yards and two scores, and Mejia added six catches for 78 yards and a touchdown. Linebacker
Brady Nowlan anchored the Southeastern defense with a game-high 10 solo tackles.